Confessions of a Six Figure Professional Blogger

How I Got a 250% Opt-In Rate Increase With No Work… With Popup Domination

Some of you may have noticed that I silently launched a new lightbox opt-in form on this blog late on Friday afternoon. I’ve already had emails asking me how I did it. The design is really professional and it also resulted in about a 250% increase in opt-ins from what I was getting using Aweber’s lightbox form. And the best thing is…. I didn’t have to design it myself or hire anybody to do it.

How cool is that?

I did it using a brand new Wordpress plug-in called Popup Domination, being released by my far-flung blogging buddy from England, Michael Dunlop.

Using Popup Domination

You install it just like any other Wordpress plug-in. You then visit the configuration screens under the Settings menu in Wordpress.

First thing you will do is select your design. The plug-in now includes 4 different styles of templates. Here are a couple of them:

Screen shot 2010-07-18 at 1.44.43 PM.png

Screen shot 2010-07-18 at 1.44.52 PM.png

With each of the 4 styles, you have 8 different color options for the button and 14 different color themes. Then, you set up your opt-in form HTML. The plug-in works with Aweber, iContact, GetResponse and Mailchimp right out of the box, however it will actually work with ANY provider because you can map your own form fields to the plug-in quite easily.

Screen shot 2010-07-18 at 1.48.37 PM.png

From there, you simply copy/paste your default opt-in form HTML as given to you by your provider. Nice and easy. I recommend you set up a separate opt-in form for tracking purposes – this way you can easily compare the performance of this form to your prior ones. (You’ll see a great result, trust me. :) )

Next, you’ll define the text and image to use inside your lightbox form. Here you can see the current setup for mine:

Screen shot 2010-07-18 at 1.50.52 PM.png

Set up your bullet point text and define your schedule. You can specify how quickly to show your opt-in to new arrivals, and how often to repeat. I’m currently testing mine with a 3 second-delay and a 7-day repeat. However, you can easily alter these (and I likely will be). Even if you don’t want it to repeat ever again, just define your repeat interval to some super long delay, like 999 days.

Now, if you’re a techie-type and want to modify some things, they’ve got that taken care of, too. From inside the plug-in, you can click on “Advanced” and get direct access to the CSS and PHP files. You can actually modify the plug-in itself if you so choose.

My Take On This

If you read Dunlop’s blog, you know that he recently launched a total redesign of IncomeDiary. One of the things he did was change the way he collected email addresses. Now, he has some things going on on-site, but this lightbox is definitely a big part of his strategy and he has been getting great results from it.

Even me… it has been on my to-do list for a little while now to beautify my lightbox opt-in. I was using Aweber’s built-in forms for awhile, but you can only customize so much with their setup. Some of the nice effects (like wrap-around borders, etc) just cannot be done using Aweber’s current lightbox forms. Which leaves me to either hire somebody to do it or attempt it myself.

For a little while, I even tried a customized opt-in form which was triggered when a person scrolled to the bottom of one of my posts. I thought it was pretty slick and I saw my friend, Erica Douglass, trying it. So, I contacted the person who did it for her and paid him to do it here. While the design and functionality was nice, it actually resulted in about a 0.5% DROP in conversion rate as compared to Aweber’s lightbox. So, I ended up reverting back to the lightbox.

As of this writing, I’ve only been running Popup Domination for a couple days, but it is resulting (so far) in about a 250% INCREASE in opt-ins as compared to the Aweber lightbox. Mind you, this is without even trying. I literally put my old copy into this form and installed it in a matter of minutes. I haven’t spent ANY time yet trying to fine-tune the copy or do much of anything new. So, just the design itself is getting me a 250% increase, with no additional work at all.

There are a couple things that I asked Michael to add to Popup Domination and he tells me he’s doing it. One is the ability to split-test multiple lightbox forms. That will be an AWESOME feature. Second is that the Aweber tracking image is being stripped out of the form HTML, meaning I cannot tell how many times the form loaded from inside of Aweber. He is fixing that, and as of the time I’m writing this post, I believe he is waiting for me to test his fix. So, I expect that issue won’t be the for long.

Let me Show You – In Video

I Absolutely Recommend This To You

It isn’t very often I see a Wordpress plug-in with the word “popup” in it and feel compelled to recommend it to anybody. But, I do highly recommend this plug-in to you if you want to build a list (and you should be).

Lightboxes work and they work like crazy. WELL-DESIGNED opt-in forms work even better, as this plug-in will prove to you. Here is why I think you should get this plug-in:

  • Paying somebody to design forms like this will cost you FAR, FAR more than this plug-in. Trust me, I know.
  • These forms are built with both aesthetics and PERFORMANCE in mind. They work, they don’t just look pretty.
  • These forms are much better than any of the email list services can provide built-in. This is the kind of thing you would normally have to pay a person to customize for you.
  • As I’ve covered a million times now, email list building is the #1 activity of your blog. Without a list, you have very little.
  • Sitting there and hoping somebody notices your boring little opt-in form in your blog’s sidebar isn’t going to cut it. They WILL notice this form.

As of this post being written, this plug-in is only $37. It is an absolute, no-brainer, total steal at that price. So, get on over there and grab it. BTW, as you watch his video, you’re going to see somebody you recognize. ;)

If you enjoyed this article, you might also like...

  1. Using Multiple Opt-Ins To Track What Works [Aweber]
  2. Blog Comments And a HUGE Wasted Opportunity
  3. Insiders: An Opt-In Technique Worth Testing. I Will Be. :-)
  4. Optimizing Your Blog’s Opt-in Rate
  5. 2 Important Updates + Webinar [News]
Six Figure Blogger Blueprint

Get your copy of the Six Figure Blogger Blueprint.

You'll Discover...

  • 3 vital questions to pick the right niche.
  • The layout for funneling traffic into your blog.
  • How this blog generates thousands of dollars monthly - without a single banner ad.

Your information will not be shared with anybody - ever.

  • Hi, Popup Domination really works! I put to one of my blogs and my optin rates got doubled, it's amazing piece of software.
  • David- don't know if you have any pull. But I am having problems with PD and I cannot get any support. I am getting complaints that some people are not able to X out of the popup and are "forced" to sign up.

    This is not what I am going for.

    I have emailed PD support and I get nothing back form them :(

    Any ideas?
  • eblogr
    really good.. just what I have been looking for.. and at $37, it is a steal.. Thanks David.
  • Dave, do you think the huge difference is because of Pop-Up Domination? Or just due to the fact that you did something different? Were you using AWeber's lightbox prior to PUD? I think I remember seeing it.
  • I bought this and my IT guys cannot get it to work on my wordpress blog at all. My blog is an older version of wordpress. Would that make a difference in Popup Domination not working? I host a wordpress blog that is the latest version of wordpress and the Popup Domination works fine there.

    If the version of wordpress is the problem, then to get Popup Domination working, what do I have to do to upgrade the version without losing all of the backlinks to my current blog and all of the historical data in my blog? Any hints on how best to upgrade without losing everything my blog has built up over the past years?
  • picseshu
    I am on the fence. Is there an alternative out there that does the same thing as this plugin?
  • Easy Essay
    I've just purchased this for my Blogs, but I am not going to implement it until I have a regular stream of traffic, or a much higher of daily visitors.

    between that is very nice sharing...!!! thanks for this nice post! :)
  • great article and post, will bookmark for sure and get updated on new posts
  • Raghu
    Great plugin, I have been using it for last 2 days, but looks like plugin will not work with cache plugins. I have W3 Cache and popup appears on every page.

    Reply from Support -
    Unfortunately due to the nature of lightboxes, they will not work with cache plugins, if you'd like me to explain further I can.

    We suggest you turn them off, or do some form of rotation with one plugin on, one plugin off.

    I'm planning to get the refund.
  • StuartMcMinigal
    I've just purchased this for my Blogs, but I am not going to implement it until I have a regular stream of traffic, or a much higher of daily visitors.
    But from looking at yours and Michaels opt-in increase it is a truely good product.

    Stuart
  • Vlu3
    Hey David, you should show us a screen shot of the increase :)
  • Thanks David, your review prompted me to purchase at a time when I had been thinking of a lightbox for a months or so and had nearly, but not quite bought another. I looked your review from your email, I do read some of them :-)
    But that just goes to show me how "it works" in part, and I am grateful for that too.
    Nice tip from Shannon about the $10 discount, worked for me.
    BTW , the install was a cinch, and the support from Pop Up Domination was excellent when it was needed.
    Phil
  • I went ahead and bought it- but it is NOT compatible with Feedburner. I emailed them and let them know my trouble and I just got back that I should make a free account with Mail Chimp- which does me no good as I have over 6000 people on my list and don't plan to switch at this point (I have done a ton of research and it does not make sense for my needs right now).

    I am hoping I will hear something back with either a fix or a way I can get my money back.
  • OK- I am responding to myself. I think I have made it work- I added an additional line of code to my feedburner html and I think it is going to function.
  • Yeah, I'm pretty sure you can make it work with Feedburner as long as they use a standard opt-in form, which I think it does. That said.... dude, Feedburner sucks. You really do need to think about moving that list to a real provider. Even if you lose some in the transition, it'll be 1000X better.
  • Anysia
    You might want to check your site on an iPhone. It's impossible to close the popup, making your post pretty much unreadable as much if it is covered up. I'm sure it looks great on a regular screen though
  • Yeah, aware of that. It was actually fixed, but something happened and I had to revert. They are busily ironing these things out, though. I've been talking with Dunlop about it.
  • Anysia
    Commenting on the iPhone is a bit of a PITA too with the Disqus system, but I didn't notice that until after I hit post comment. :) Glad to know they're working on it though since I did buy the plugin (now that I've figured out a niche 7 months after starting BMC I'll be needing it! :D).
  • Cool David, thanks for the heads up... I might be trying this one out myself. :)

    c
  • Great Plugin and I purchased it through your link, but I went back to check something out and when I closed out the browser he was offering a $10 discount. I hate this type of marketing.

    So if you are going to get this, go to the page and then exit. There is a $10 discount waiting for you there.

    Man that type of desperation marketing chaps my hide.

    Shannon
  • Anysia
    Thanks for mentioning this. I notice a mea culpa was sent out this morning from the seller about this particular tactic so he may have changed his marketing.
  • David

    I am going to give this a test run - thanks for the info

    Peter
    Fitness over 50
  • Hey Dave,

    This looks really cool. I noticed the new lightbox last week and it looks fantastic. Really big and make a great impression. I use Aweber for mine and I think it's time to add some oomph using Michael's plugin. Thanks for the recommendation. I know a lot of people don't like lightboxes, but they certainly work. Most of my subscribers coming from the lightbox on my site.

    Thanks,
    Karen
  • Wow....great timing as always!

    I FINALLY signed up with Aweber last week and spent the weekend updating my lists and using their online form generator to make my lightbox and sidebar sign-ups.

    But of course I was REALLY wishing i could customize the forms more than Aweber's great service allows......and Mr. Risley comes to the rescue......again heh heh.

    I'm going to wait a couple weeks and see how the Aweber forms do, especially with the split testing, and then buy this plug-in to get it exactly how I want it.

    Thanks again for some great and timely info.....!
  • OMG! This is particularly useful, David. Thank you. I didn't we can do it so easily now - used to tear my hair and heart out doing the design...
  • Dood. I am going to try this! Thanks!
  • Yeah, I'm looking forward to doing some split testing on it, too. But, these form designs are really nice.
  • Monte
    Hi Dave,

    Being a regular visitor to your blog I had to clear my cache (cookies) to see your pop up.

    Very nice, I have bought it and installed it on my test blog, now I have to configure it, I was thinking of doing a rotation through my e-courses, a different e-course on the third time someone reads the blog.

    Have to give it some more thought, getting ready to test it on my test blog today.
  • srinirao
    David,

    This is brilliant and simple. I love it and I'll be implementing it in the next day or two. Thanks for sharing.
  • Dave, what techie thing gives you the comment and reactions input on each blog as you scroll down the home page?

    "5 Comments and 0 Reactions"

    Don't you love my Geek talk?
  • That's just Disqus. Disqus.com - its the comment system I use. Different than Wordpress.
  • Looks like an awesome plugin. How often do you have it show to a visitor? Every time they come here, once-in-awhile, or once unless they clear their cookies?
  • You can control that in the plug-in. Watch my video and I show the "Schedule" options. :-)
  • Great post, Dave. Thanks!

    Either I don't see it because I'm a subscriber already or I just don't know what I'm looking for but I'm missing it here. Could be it's just too early on a Monday.

    That said, obviously this works best if you have a freebie offering but in the interim do you think it would be productive to have it for a no-frill opt in? I'm still working on the renovation of my blog and getting everything going and thinking it might be good to start off with it.
  • Yeah, you could always spell out the benefits of being on your list at all. You have to put something in the form. :-)
  • Rock n roll, man. I expected this to cost way more. A very nice, comprehensive review. I'm gonna give this a whirl on a new site. Thanks for the insight :-)
blog comments powered by Disqus